Activists blame scientists, GMOs for dying iconic Italian olive trees, block GM solution

|

The olive tree is one of Italy’s two national trees. Images are easily evoked of olive-oil infused cuisine, and rolling acres of sun-drenched orchards, striped with row after row of often century-old olive trees.

Now, in Southern Italy at least, at least one million of those iconic olive trees are dying. While scientists have worked on determining a cause, certain anti-GMO groups have pointed to genetic modification experiments and the Italian government has been investigating the scientists themselves as culprits.

An olive die-off

Starting in 2013, farmers and agricultural officials started recording large scale leaf scorch and die-off of olive trees in the southern part of the country, in the Puglia region. Investigators found three pests that appeared to contribute to the issue: the leopard moth, several species of fungus, and a bacteria called Xylella fastidiosa.

The outbreak of Xylella was the first confirmed occurrence in Europe. For years, the bacteria have plagued olive, citrus and ornamental oleander plants in North and South America. Scientists conducted molecular analyses to determine the existence of Xylella and fungal species (which also were new to Europe), and to search for the existence of new or unusual strains of the bacteria that could lend more evidence to the source of the unprecedented outbreak.

The Italian government has instituted emergency measures, including cutting down trees, to try and contain the outbreak. However, the European Food Safety Authority warned that their scientists indicated that Xylella could spread throughout Europe despite these measures. In fact, an infestation was discovered in Corsica in July by French authorities. The EFSA recommended screened-in greenhouse production, certification for nursery-grown plants, eradication of infected insects, and insecticides for imported plants. That last measure was not popular with Italian growers, who have resisted pesticides and other chemical applications for years.

Activists rush in with blame

And the farmers’ resistance may have ushered in more than the outbreak. While evidence has shown clearly that the bacteria was brought in by insects imported from Central America, anti-GMO activists have started openly questioning whether scientists may have instituted a “covert assault by the biotech industry.” And the Italian government is investigating the scientists.

Anti-GMO activists pointed to what they believe is a hasty blame on Xylella as the sole reason for the outbreak, and claim that scientists had in 2010 brought samples of Xylella to a meeting in Bari, Italy, and they suggested that it may have got loose. Accusations have ranged from a plot by Monsanto to introduce strains of olive trees that resist the bacteria, to a deliberate plot to eradicate olive trees, to even a test to determine Europe’s response to a bioterrorist attack.

Police action

A second conspiracy scenario has attracted Italian police. This scheme involves the deliberate release of Xylella (via insect vectors and other methods), which killed the olive trees, and forced farmers to sell their land to land developers at low prices. The result? Cheaper development of hotels and other tourist attractions in the area. The fact that groves of olive trees on rural hillsides were part of the region’s attractiveness was not mentioned in this conspiracy theory.

Scientists with the CNR Institute for Sustainable Plant Protection (IPSP) were questioned by Italian police earlier last summer. They, the Italian Ministry of Agriculture, and other scientists investigating the outbreak also have had their computers and documents confiscated, in addition to more questioning by the police. It has turned out, according to the scientists interviewed, that police were following up on the “claims” initiated by anti-GMO and local activists.

Where science could have helped over hype

Growers and scientists have expressed hope for olive trees in southern Italy nonetheless. So far, just about a million trees are affected, just a fraction of the 11 million trees in the region. In addition, the Xylella in Italy is a perfect match to the Xylella in trees from Costa Rica. This is the same Xylella that has infected plants in Brazil and California — and while pest management is expensive, it has prevented a complete die-off.

Ironically, anti-GMO activists may have eliminated one promising solution to the Xylella outbreak just a year before it was discovered. Since 1982, scientists had been working on various ways to genetically engineer resistance to fungal and bacterial infections in olive trees, including growing test trees in Italy. In 2012, the Italian government ordered these new strains of trees destroyed, to comply with a law banning field research on genetically engineered plants.

Instead of reaping die-offs sown by hysteria, the country’s olive growers could have used modern technology to reap healthy olive trees.

Andrew Porterfield is a writer, editor and communications consultant for academic institutions, companies and non-profits in the life sciences. He is based in Camarillo, California. Follow @AMPorterfield on Twitter.

  • First Officer

    I strongly recommend that the scientists involved seek political asylum abroad. This, blame the scientists situation in Italy has happened before, just a few years ago with the Abruzzo earthquake.

    http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/italy-abruzzo-earthquake-scientist-trial/

    • Loren Eaton

      Yes….but if I stay, maybe I can get charged with the Kennedy assassination.

  • Good4U

    A couple of decades ago the Italian government banned nuclear power plants from being built to generate electricity. Now Italy buys much of their electricity from France…which generates it from nuclear power.

    • RobertWager

      Hmmm just like 40 million tonnes of GE feed sold to Europe each year while EU farmers are banned from growing same GE crops. and so it goes…

    • Warren Lauzon

      Just like they ban GMO grains, but then import millions of tons of it.

  • First Officer

    First Geologists, now biologists, geneticists. It may behoove all scientists residing in Italy to leave before their time comes.

    • Truly – why would a scientist want to stay in Italy if you can be investigated for doing your job and trying to save a national industry?

      • First Officer

        And jailed for it too !

  • RobertWager

    Funny a government sponsored university GE maize trial found huge benefits to Bt maize. Gov refused to publish results. and so it goes…

  • Warren Lauzon

    Italy seems to be very good at blaming scientists for all their failures and disasters. If they are not putting geologists in jail for not predicting earthquakes, or for not predicting an eruption, they go after any other target that might involve a scientist. Surprised that all the Italian scientists have not emigrated out of Italy.