The GLP is committed to full transparency. Download and review our just-released 2019 Annual Report.

Challenging Nature’s decision to run a stem cell advertisement portrayed as research

Readers of Nature, one of the world’s most important scientific journals, might have been struck recently by an audacious claim appearing on its website about a possible stem cell treatment for heart attacks.

The published item asserted that MUSE cells, a subset of stem cells, could regenerate heart tissue after acute myocardial infarctions, which are deadly sudden heart attacks. This could be a significant advance in both cardiac treatment and the use of stem cells.

Here’s the problem. The published item wasn’t a peer-reviewed article subject to Nature’s rigorous professional vetting procedure. It was an advertisement.

2-27-2019 nature
Advertising, or the real thing? A stem cell researcher thought this ad in Nature could be mistaken for a peer-reviewed article. Nature removed the ad. Image credit: Nature/Knoepfler

After [stem cell expert Paul] Knoepfler’s inquiry, the journal said, “we reviewed the ad and determined that it didn’t fully meet the guidelines we set ourselves for paid content” and removed it. Nature told Knoepfler that such advertising material wasn’t subject to indexing for scholarly databases and therefore wouldn’t penetrate the research mainstream.

Related article:  'Good Reasons for Bad Feelings': Understanding evolution’s role in anxiety, depression and making us human

“How can a research article be an advertisement?” Knoepfler asked on his blog. “I don’t think it should be possible. The field of science doesn’t need to blur the line between research articles and ads.”

Read full, original post: Did a world-famous science journal become a shill for a questionable stem cell claim?

The GLP aggregated and excerpted this article to reflect the diversity of news, opinion, and analysis. Click the link above to read the full, original article.
News on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.
Optional. Mail on special occasions.

Send this to a friend