Atheists are mutants? Dissecting a ‘genetics’ paper without genetics

3-19-2019 god and the laws of science genetics vs evolution jm
Image credit: Apologetics Press

I just came across a paper with an interesting title: The Mutant Says in His Heart, “There Is No God”.

The conclusions of this work are even more interesting. According to the authors, Edward Dutton et al., humans evolved to be religious and atheism is caused (in part) by mutational damage to our normal, religious DNA. Atheists, in other words, are genetic degenerates.

Despite the talk of mutations, there is no genetics in this paper. No atheist genomes were sequenced and found to be mutated. Rather, Dutton et al. claim (mostly on the basis of a review of previous literature) that atheists have elevated rates of proxy measures of genetic health or ‘mutational load’, namely ill-health, autism, and left-handedness. This, they say, is consistent with atheism being a manifestation of “increasing genetic mutation affecting the mind”.

…

There is much better evidence for an atheism-intelligence link than there is for an atheism-autism or atheism-handedness one. Yet how can high intelligence be compatible with the idea that atheists have harmful mutations?

…

Overall, I found it very hard to believe in the conclusions of this paper. Perhaps my skepticism is merely a reflection of my dodgy genetics?

Read full, original post: Are Atheists Genetically Damaged?

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

BEMT Lotion for Freckled Skin
Burned by FDA bureaucracy: Why Americans waited decades for cancer-preventing sunscreen
Screenshot-2026-11-12-at-11.22.35-AM
The science of an orgasm: It’s a lot more varied and complex than you might think
Nicotine Products on Gray Marble
Comparing vaping, nicotine patches and cigarettes: Not ‘safe vs. dangerous’  but ‘less harmful vs. more harmful’
Screenshot-2026-11-16-at-1.18.40-PM
‘Measles fiasco one of many healthcare failures’: Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy says it's time to fire RFK Jr.
Screenshot-2026-11-09-at-1.40.16-PM
As measles cases continue to surge, RFK Jr. blocks CDC scientists from issuing emergency alert warning unvaccinated pregnant women of significantly increased risks
Man in Green “Make America Healthy Again” Cap
Viewpoint: MAHA 2.0? Will the wellness grifters rescue RFK Jr.?
ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
Screenshot-2026-11-13-at-11.57.01-AM
JAMA survey: Who’s most likely to embrace the RFK Jr.-fueled lie that vaccines cause autism? Men, adults 35–44, blacks and Republicans
Crisp Physicians’ Protest Sign Close-Up
‘He’s a disgrace’: Some newly-elected legislators and health groups call for RFK Jr. impeachment 
Screenshot 2026-11-13 at 11.41
Viewpoint: Talent-crushing and mired in chaos: The unnerving story of how Trump cuts are driving out disillusioned young scientists
Contrasting Portraits and Family Story
Congressional investigation targets RFK Jr.: Documents show HHS chief lied multiple times during his confirmation hearings
Screenshot-2026-11-13-at-10.02.02-AM
Viewpoint: Why it’s such a big deal that under Trump-RFK Jr., the U.S. has lost its ‘measles-free’ status  
Screenshot-2026-11-17-at-12.56.22-PM
RFK Jr.’s CDC blocked measles risk alert for pregnant women; 112 contracted the disease, and one-quarter were hospitalized
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.