Data centers have quietly become the most contentious infrastructure fight in America, and the opposition is borrowing its playbook straight from the anti-pipeline movement. As outlined by Amy Harder for Axios, a bipartisan coalition of ranchers, environmentalists and rural conservatives has turned against the AI boom’s server farms with a speed that caught even industry insiders off guard. Texas Governor Greg Abbott went from courting data centers to pumping the brakes on them in roughly three months.
From Keystone XL to Server Farms
The parallels to past fossil fuel fights are hard to miss. Concerns about water consumption, spiking electricity bills, and out-of-state corporations swallowing up farmland echo almost exactly the arguments once used against the Keystone XL pipeline.
“We just want to make sure when these massive infrastructure projects are being built, that they’re not leaving harms in the communities,” said Jane Kleeb, co-founder of Bold Alliance and chair of the Nebraska Democratic Party, who built her activist resume fighting Keystone XL over a decade ago.
Country icon Willie Nelson, who has more than a million Instagram followers, added celebrity firepower to the cause this summer. In an open letter to fans, he wrote: “The last thing we need is a loud, water thieving, light polluting, data center anywhere near our town (or any others for that matter).”
The Money Problem
Texas’s data center boom also has a budget problem. The state’s sales-tax exemption for data centers is projected to cost roughly a billion dollars a year, according to the Texas Tribune, and lawmakers are now scrutinizing the very incentives they used to lure the industry.
“It would be very difficult for lawmakers to argue that these companies with their significant financial wherewithal require tax exemption,” said Timothy Fox, an analyst at ClearView Energy Partners.
Related on the SLP
|
Related on the SLP
Viewpoint: Data center rejections hit 275 in 2026. Opponents are not the Luddites portrayed by the media
|
All of this has made data centers a genuine wedge issue heading into November. Axios reports the fights have “solidified as a top flashpoint in this year’s midterm elections,” and Fox expects them to remain “the most pressing energy topic before state legislatures next year.”
The industry’s defense leans on the idea that a few “bad actors” give everyone else a bad name. Kleeb, who heard the same line from oil and gas executives for years, isn’t buying it: “Pipeline companies used to say this, too. If that’s true, name them and put out a set of policy suggestions that you believe are the proper guardrails around data centers.”


















