Why smart people believe nonsense?

Credit: Portland Community College
Credit: Portland Community College

The intuitive explanation is straightforward: people believe fake stories because they lack knowledge or education. The “science literacy model,” which dominated efforts to counter disinformation for decades, holds that the solution is to educate people, present evidence, and correct errors. However, more recent research shows that this model is incorrect — or, at the very least, seriously incomplete.

In 2017, Dan Kahan of Yale University examined what is known as identity-protective cognition and identified a paradox: intelligent, well-educated individuals do not become more objective on contentious political issues. On the contrary, they defend their group’s position even more firmly. They deploy their cognitive abilities not to seek the truth, but to justify what they already believe.

Mis- and disinformation are distorting science and public policy. Subscribe to our Daily and Weekly Digests for incisive coverage of ‘disruptive’ innovations in AI, agricultural biotechnology, food, chemicals, nuclear energy, vaccines, and other disruptive innovations.

Gordon Pennycook and David G. Rand (2019, Cognition) reached a somewhat different conclusion: susceptibility to fake news is better explained not by motivated reasoning, but by insufficient cognitive effort. In other words, people believe fake news not because they interpret it through the lens of their prior beliefs (identity-protective cognition), but because they fail to evaluate it critically. …

These two conclusions do not contradict each other. Rather, they describe different conditions. When a belief has not yet become part of one’s identity, it may be sufficient to pause and reflect. However, once it has, even an intelligent person may deploy their full cognitive capacity to defend a false belief.

This is an excerpt. Read the original post here

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

Screenshot-2026-11-16-at-2.37.32-PM
30 years of GMO farming: Is the boom in glyphosate and glufosinate use harming the environment? Data show they’re the most sustainable choice
Nurturing Care Beneath the Crunchy Moms Logo
Crunchy Moms disinformation flood: Zuckerberg's Facebook has opened floodgates on measles and vaccines
Stormlit Portrait Over Golden Mountains
Searching for life where no one thought to look: A renowned astrophysicist’s seemingly quixotic quest to explore Venus’s clouds
ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
Soybean Harvest in Cupped Hands
30 years of GMO farming: Defying cynics, we’ve had larger harvests, lower costs, and $385 billion in added global farmer income
Screenshot-2026-11-19-at-7.23.23-PM
Viewpoint: After a yearlong hiatus, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force is back in business—gutted by RFK Jr. and promoting junk science
Screenshot-2026-11-19-at-7.54.57-PM
European General Court sides with scientists, dismisses activist claims that glyphosate is toxically dangerous
Screenshot-2026-11-17-at-12.18.09-PM
Challenging glyphosate fear-mongering: Statewide Nebraska study finds no link between weedkiller use and non-Hodgkin lymphoma
Nicotine Products on Gray Marble
Comparing vaping, nicotine patches and cigarettes: Not ‘safe vs. dangerous’  but ‘less harmful vs. more harmful’
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.