Logic for using precautionary principle with GMOs faulty

The GLP aggregated and excerpted this blog/article to reflect the diversity of news, opinion and analysis.

A working paper coauthored by financier Nassim Taleb and several other scholars argues that the creation of GMOs through DNA-splicing is substantially more dangerous than producing new plant varieties through selective breeding.

This essay rebuts their three main arguments

  1. The Top-Down Rebuttal: Taleb’s distinction between top-down DNA-splicing versus bottom-up natural selection and selective breeding is misleading. The same top-down and bottom-up processes occur with natural selection, selective breeding, and DNA-splicing alike. In all cases, there is a top-down determinant: the environment itself “selects” which organisms are fit to survive in it and which are not. Conversely, in all three processes, the organism must “earn” its survival through adapting itself bottom-up to the environment.
  2. The Fast Evolution Rebuttal: Contrary to Taleb’s assumptions, there are case studies of evolution happening quickly under selective breeding, thus undermining Taleb’s claim that the rapidity of DNA-splicing renders it incomparable to selective breeding.
  3. The Extreme Change Rebuttal: Taking DNA from one species and splicing it into another is not extreme when one considers the nature of DNA. DNA is a sequence of four molecules — guanine, adenine, thymine, and cytosine.  Every type of genetic engineering rearranges this sequence.  If putting a fish DNA sequence into a tomato’s DNA sequence amounts to a relatively small rearrangement of the molecules, it might not be as radical a rearrangement of DNA as what takes place when selective breeding randomly sorts thousands of genes.

For these reasons, Taleb and company fail to demonstrate that DNA-splicing techniques pose a danger to human beings or the ecosystem beyond anything that commences with selective breeding.

Read full, original post:  Nassim Taleb’s False Dichotomy of Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches to Farming With Respect to GMOs

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

Nurturing Care Beneath the Crunchy Moms Logo
Crunchy Moms disinformation flood: Zuckerberg's Facebook has opened floodgates on measles and vaccines
Screenshot-2026-11-19-at-7.54.57-PM
European General Court sides with scientists, dismisses activist claims that glyphosate is toxically dangerous
Screenshot-2026-11-16-at-2.37.32-PM
30 years of GMO farming: Is the boom in glyphosate and glufosinate use harming the environment? Data show they’re the most sustainable choice
Soybean Harvest in Cupped Hands
30 years of GMO farming: Defying cynics, we’ve had larger harvests, lower costs, and $385 billion in added global farmer income
Stormlit Portrait Over Golden Mountains
Searching for life where no one thought to look: A renowned astrophysicist’s seemingly quixotic quest to explore Venus’s clouds
gut health
Health vs. hype on gut health: We are flooded by misinformation
Screenshot-2026-11-19-at-7.23.23-PM
Viewpoint: After a yearlong hiatus, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force is back in business—gutted by RFK Jr. and promoting junk science
Screenshot-2026-11-18-at-2.44.24-PM
Why should thousands of Americans die every year waiting for a kidney transplant? There’s an easy fix to this morbid reality
Screenshot-2026-11-17-at-12.18.09-PM
Challenging glyphosate fear-mongering: Statewide Nebraska study finds no link between weedkiller use and non-Hodgkin lymphoma
ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.