The GLP is committed to full transparency. Download and review our 2019 Annual Report

Calling for a ‘richer’ global conversation about CRISPR, gene editing

The GLP curated this excerpt as part of a daily selection of biotechnology-related news, opinion and analysis.

Over the past three years, leading scientists have called for global deliberation on the possible effects of gene editing on the human future. In our view, the discussions that have taken place fall far short of the expansive, cosmopolitan conversation that is needed.

An important milestone was the International Summit on Human Gene Editing, held in Washington DC in December 2015.

[However,] the meeting format offered little opportunity for deeper listening or learning.

Instead, it encouraged an all-too-common pattern. Discussion split into two camps: scientific experts explored technical issues, whereas scholars who study science and society addressed questions about the possible disruption to social norms. The two camps did not inform each other.

To break out of this bifurcation between the ‘science’ and the ‘ethics’, methods must be found to get people to engage substantively with each other. In our view, an entirely new type of infrastructure is needed to promote a richer, more complex conversation — one that does not originate from scientific research agendas but that instead invites multiple viewpoints.

Related article:  Viewpoint: The problem with personalized medicine is that 'statistics are being misinterpreted'

We advocate the establishment of a global observatory for gene editing, as a crucial step to determining how the potential of science can be better steered by the values and priorities of society.

An international, interdisciplinary observatory would be an important step in this direction.

Editor’s note: Sheila Jasanoff is a professor of science and technology studies at the Harvard Kennedy School. Benjamin Hurlbut is associate professor of biology and society at Arizona State University.

Read full, original post: A global observatory for gene editing

News on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.
Optional. Mail on special occasions.

Send this to a friend