How faulty peer review system allowed Nature to publish weak aging study

Nature

On Dutch Demography Day in November, the French demographer Jean-Marie Robine stood behind the lectern in the Utrecht Academy Building. He had flown in from Montpellier for the introductory lecture of the day. It was on an important social topic: the increasing life span of humans.

…

But after about five minutes, he could not avoid talking about a recent article in Nature by three complete unknowns in the field. It was published on 5 October, under the title Evidence for a limit to human lifespan. Following a demographic analysis, three geneticists from New York concluded that people will never grow older than approximately 115.

…
Only during the Q&A did a PhD student say it out loud: “Frankly, this is the weakest paper I have read in a top journal.” Robine did not comment….

How could this article appear in one of the world’s leading scientific journals? It’s a question which is regularly asked in the academic world, but never answered.

According to Nature, the peer-review process is rigorous and independent, with the claims of each paper being weighed against the many others. But my conversations yielded a very different, disconcerting picture. The authors said their reviewers had a better grasp of the material than they did themselves. The reviewers knew that. They had criticisms, yet they did not scrutinise a large part of the analysis at all. And Nature let it slide….

The GLP aggregated and excerpted this blog/article to reflect the diversity of news, opinion, and analysis. Read full, original post: Peer review post-mortem: how a flawed aging study was published in Nature

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

Screenshot-2026-11-06-at-12.33.30-PM
Freaked out: Is it ethically okay to create animals with human tissue–including from the brain to help save lives?
Contrasting Portraits and Family Story
Congressional investigation targets RFK Jr.: Documents show HHS chief lied multiple times during his confirmation hearings
ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
Screenshot-2026-11-13-at-10.02.02-AM
Viewpoint: Why it’s such a big deal that under Trump-RFK Jr., the U.S. has lost its ‘measles-free’ status  
Glossy Chocolate in Glass Petri Dish
Chocolate-making cocoa beans are increasingly in short supply. There may be a biotech fix
Screenshot-2026-11-13-at-2.44.51-PM
Viewpoint: How will the Democratic sweep impact abortion rights 
Screenshot-2026-11-13-at-11.57.01-AM
JAMA survey: Who’s most likely to embrace the RFK Jr.-fueled lie that vaccines cause autism? Men, adults 35–44, blacks and Republicans
Watercolor U.S
Cataloging the science-denying road to America losing its global measles-free status
eden green vertical farm facility
Why vertical farming is not the panacea for our food production crisis that its proponents claim
Children’s Health Defense Press Conference
As measles deaths among the unvaccinated hit a 35-year high, Kennedy-founded Children’s Health Defense bizarrely blames doctors for slow-walking a cure
Professional Portrait Earth Backdrop
Viewpoint: November 13 is the long-predicted global doomsday. How a respected scientist got population growth catastrophe predictions so spectacularly wrong—fueling decades of junk science
Energetic Speaker on Stage
Viewpoint: Why are the stars of the MAHA revolution standing by convicted rapist — and conservative firebrand — Russell Brand?
Nicotine Products on Gray Marble
Comparing vaping, nicotine patches and cigarettes: Not ‘safe vs. dangerous’  but ‘less harmful vs. more harmful’
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.