Should EU regulate CRISPR crops based on modification process or final product?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The GLP aggregated and excerpted this blog/article to reflect the diversity of news, opinion and analysis.

. . .Which of the following would you regard as genetic modification?

A: Adding a gene from another organism
B: Inducing mutations with radiation or toxic chemicals
C: Making a single precise change to an organism’s genome

For me, the answer is D: All of the above. For the European Commission, though, the answer is “A – yes, B – no, and C – well, we can’t make up our minds.”

This position has never made any sense and now, with the CRISPR gene-editing revolution, it appears even more ludicrous.

. . . .

. . . [G]ene editing works by exploiting natural recombination. . .  the simplest form merely involves cutting DNA at a specific site. When the cell repairs the damage, it often adds or deletes a few DNA letters. Exactly the same kind of mutations occur naturally. . .

. . . .Modern breeders . . . zap plants with radiation or DNA-damaging chemicals, and then screen thousands of cells to find one with the desired change. The EU has specifically ruled that mutagenesis as this is known (option B above) does not count as genetic modification. . . .

The EU. . .has yet to decide whether simple gene editing (option C above) counts as genetic modification. Rationally, it makes no sense to subject gene-edited organisms to far greater scrutiny than the products of mutagenesis when the end result can be identical. If anything, mutagenesis is riskier because it is far less precise.

. . . .

. . .[W]e need to move to a system that focuses not on how new strains of plants and animals are created but whether they have been changed in a way that could harm people or damage the environment. . . .

Read full, original post: Judge gene-edited crops by what they do, not how they are made

Outbreak Featured
Infographic: Gene transfer mystery — How 'antifreeze' genes jumped from one species to another without sex

Infographic: Gene transfer mystery — How ‘antifreeze’ genes jumped from one species to another without sex

It isn’t surprising... that herrings and smelts, two groups of fish that commonly roam the northernmost reaches of the Atlantic ...
a bee covered in pollen x

Are GMOs and pesticides threatening bees?

First introduced in 1995, neonicotinoids ...
glp menu logo outlined

Newsletter Subscription

* indicates required
Email Lists
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.