‘Culture of confrontation’: Professor on abusive use of Freedom of Information Act in GMO debate

Screen Shot at PM

[Editor’s note: David Zilberman is a professor of agriculture and resource economics at UC-Berkeley.]

[A] few weeks ago, I received a letter informing me that Mr. Russell Carollo – who I discovered is a Pulitzer-winning author — wants access to all the records of private funding of my university research and all my communication related to GMOs and related topics. … [H]e might have suspected that I [am] a paid agent of Monsanto.

Googling my name he could have easily discovered Were you paid by Monsanto? • The Berkeley Blog, where I state that I received $10,000 for reviewing some papers for Monsanto (out of millions of dollars of support grants for my research over the years from many sources). He would have known that I have made many contributions to support environmental causes. He could even have called or emailed me … and he would have better knowledge about his “suspect.” If after this initial and more personal investigation he would have asked me to provide him with information, I would have been happy to oblige according to the FOIA.

I am left with a feeling of disappointment in our culture of confrontation and lack of collegiality. … In a way, FOIA is like GMOs, a very valuable tool, which has to be applied with care.

The GLP aggregated and excerpted this blog/article to reflect the diversity of news, opinion, and analysis. Read full, original post: Do your homework before you apply FOIA

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
ChatGPT-Image-Aug-28-2026-03_33_46-PM
Viewpoint: Bad science—Five bogus Trump administration claims about vaccines and autism
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-13-2026-10_24_17-AM
Bayer urges court to approve $7.25 billion Monsanto Roundup settlement that could limit its future liabilities
Screenshot-2026-09-10-at-12.20.19-PM
'Jet fuel didn't melt the steel': 9/11 conspiracy theories debunked
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-2-2026-10_30_14-PM
Zero: That is the official American measles death toll for 2026. Here is what RFK Jr.’s CDC leaves out.
Screenshot-2026-09-14-at-10.52.30-AM
AI is being used in dangerous bioscience experiments
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-14-2026-11_36_25-AM
How the reckless AI race among Anthropic, OpenAI and China spawned today’s safety crisis
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-15-2026-06_05_13-PM
CRISPR fine-tuning unlocks vitamin C-rich potatoes without yield loss
Screenshot-2026-09-14-at-3.07.56-PM
Trump EPA rolls back power-plant climate rules—and moves to block future carbon limits
screenshot at  am
‘Glyphosate is not carcinogenic’: Independent EU chemical oversight agency reaffirms—for the 3rd time in 9 years—that the herbicide is safe-as-used
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-15-2026-05_59_18-PM
RFK Jr. spent two years distancing himself from Children’s Health Defense. Now he’s keynoting its anti-vaccine DC conference.
ChatGPT-Image-Sep-14-2026-02_57_24-PM
Viewpoint: 6 Atlantic Council expert opinions on the U.S., China and the AI safety crisis
Screenshot-2026-08-04-at-11.36.16-AM
Viewpoint: Emotion-driven stories of doctors allegedly ignoring patient concerns are driving vaccine hesitancy
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.