Viewpoint: Redefining ‘medically necessary’ — Debate unfolds over how to cover ‘off label’ treatments for rare diseases

Credit: Stephen Savage
Credit: Stephen Savage

The term “medically necessary” is the yardstick by which insurance companies, including Medicare and Medicaid, decide if they will pay for a particular treatment. For the millions of Americans living with rare diseases, most of which do not have FDA-approved treatments, identifying a treatment as medically necessary can be a lifeline — or the end of the line.

Mis- and disinformation are distorting science and public policy. Subscribe to our Daily and Weekly Digests for incisive coverage of ‘disruptive’ innovations in AI, agricultural biotechnology, food, chemicals, nuclear energy, vaccines, and other disruptive innovations.

A drug’s label includes copious information about its chemical composition, dosing instructions, and what conditions it has been approved to treat. When a clinician prescribes a treatment for an off-label use — one not listed on the label — an insurer will make a coverage decision based on special medical references known as compendia…. However, there are no rare-disease compendia to track off-label treatment protocols.

…

Marc [Yale] lives with mucous membrane pemphigoid, a rare, life-threatening autoimmune disease that causes blistering lesions throughout the body. He fought with his health insurer for two years to get the right treatment — a drug that is the standard of care for his very rare condition. He was told that the treatment his doctors prescribed was off-label, experimental, and not on any compendia, and his insurer insisted that he use other medications instead. While Marc fought with his insurer, he lost his eyesight, had to stop working, and was hospitalized. 

This is an excerpt. Read the original post here

Related Articles

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Infographic: Global regulatory and health research agencies on whether glyphosate causes cancer

Does glyphosate—the world's most heavily-used herbicide—pose serious harm to humans? Is it carcinogenic? Those issues are of both legal and ...

Most Popular

Bayer Crop Circle in Golden Wheat
Making fertilizer from thin air: Bayer’s gene-editing innovation could dramatically cut chemical fertilizer use in growing food
Glossy Plastic Bag of Tokens and Labels
Viewpoint: How CNN got played by environmental activists pushing a plastics scare and litigation agenda
Screenshot-2026-10-30-at-10.55.54-AM
Longevity scandal: The huckster who validates the ‘oldest people in the world’ claims
Picture1
Viewpoint: How badly is the U.S. food-safety net fraying? FDA’s bungled handling of the tainted lettuce crisis deepens concerns over cuts to disease tracking and response
Screenshot-2026-10-28-at-3.00.44-PM
Viewpoint: Activist attacks on corporations increasingly depend on "attribution" science to target oil companies for global climate change
Red and Green Embroidered Campaign Caps
Viewpoint: The fragile (and often bizarre) MAHA-MAGA-far left health-and-chemicals coalition is fracturing. Here’s why
Reaching Through the Woven Sky
Challenging genetic modification rejectionists: Our evolving food system has relied on science for thousands of years
ChatGPT-Image-Mar-10-2026-01_39_01-PM
Viewpoint—“Miracle molecule” debunked: Why acemannan supplements don’t work
Screenshot-2026-11-03-at-3.16.18-PM
Trump is “terminating” Biden-era rule aimed at cutting climate-warming methane emissions from oil and gas drilling
Screenshot-2026-10-21-at-11.30.51-AM
Viewpoint: Yes, our food system stinks, but the attack of ultra-processed foods is often misplaced
Robots in a Futuristic Conference Meeting
Helpful until we’re helpless? Researchers warn AI is gradually eroding human control
Patriotic Flag in a Glass Flask
Viewpoint: America Last: From the Pentagon to universities, Trump’s corruption of science could inflict lasting, irreversible damage on U.S. research
Screenshot 2026-07-29 at 10.40
The COVID vaccine turbo cancer scare is back. Science still proves it’s wrong.
glp menu logo outlined

Get news on human & agricultural genetics and biotechnology delivered to your inbox.